Skip to content

Pinoy Idol judges – HUWAT???

January 20, 2008

Nabigla talaga ako after reading the names of the judges of Pinoy Idol – the name given by GMA 7 to the Season 2 of Philippine Idol.

The first Judge is Ogie Alcasid. For me, two thumbs up for choosing him as one of the jurors. He’s a great composer/songwriter and singer.

The next Judge is like Randy Jackson..

Wyngard Tracy.

Now I think they’ve copied AI by doing this which is what ABC 5 didn’t do.. They didn’t put a Simon, Randy and Paula among the judges for the first season. Oh well, they say Wyngard is a star maker.

Next.. janjananan!

Ladies and gentlemen, Judge #3 is non other than Jolina Magdangal! Astig! Lupet!

First thing that came in to mind “she’s not perfect for the job”. But then i told myself, “why not give it a try?”

I don’t want to say negative things about Jolina, i don’t know her capabilities. But from what i know about her, i think she’s not fit to be a judge in PI.  But lets see….

Oh, and the Host for Pinoy Idol will be…

Raymond Gutierrez

So what happened to the old team? I read Ryan Agoncillo will be the Host of Pinoy Dream Academy . He will be still be working with Mr. C – Ryan Cayabyab who will be the head master.

I dunno what happened to tita pilits  and Francis M.

7 Comments leave one →
  1. January 22, 2008 11:59 am

    To be honest I’m not impressed (actually disappointed) with their team mainly because they’re too young to be judging and I don’t think they will be able to judge without the life experiences (that Randy, Simon, and Paula have) that comes with age.

    I was happy when Idol went to GMA coz I like GMA but my enthusiasm was dampened by the team that they gathered.

  2. jpk permalink
    January 22, 2008 4:29 pm

    As long as theres an Idol franchise in the philippines, i dont care what will be the title.

  3. drew permalink
    January 28, 2008 9:56 pm

    let’s just see… too early to judge d team…. and oh, btw, Jolina’s was trained by no less than MR RYAN CAYABYAB cmula pa noon.. im a singer too… so alam ko ung capabilities nya. kung tama b ung notes and evrything… hnd ako mka jolina pero, pansinin nyo kumanta si jolens, all in the right tune… right breathing and all that… kung sa training lng, wlang pguusapan ky jolens… fair nman ung pgpili sa knya as one of the judges.. let’s see kung anong kayang ibuga ng tatlo… and jusko nman, kht nman cno pwede mgjudge dun, hnd nman cla ang ngpapatakbo ng shows… actually, ang taong bayan prn ang huhusga sa mga contestants… magaling man o hindi… tignan nyo… un b ang FAIR?… 😉 peace out…

  4. drew permalink
    January 28, 2008 10:07 pm

    OGIE ALCASID is one of the most respected Composers in the country. kht nga ABSCBN, sa knya ngpapa-compose ng mga themesong nla. ang last ung sa LOBO ni Angel swanget-tabingi-ngipin db? LOLZ

    WYNGARD TRACY is also one of the respected and top-of-the-line managers in the industry.

    well, si JOLINA M lng ang bata, ang alam ko she’s turning 30 dis year.

    ***its not naman about the age.. but ung capability mo as a judge…and the credentials.***

    hindi nman lahat ng matanda eh magaling na…. db? 😉

    mas ok na rin sana kung ung sa PPS dati. Jaya-Direk Floy and Dany Tan.

    pero ok na yan para maiba nman.

  5. james permalink
    March 4, 2008 4:27 pm

    for me Mr. ogie alcasid lang naman ang bagay magjudge dyan………jolina…pwd na rin pero kulang pa sa karanasan…tracy oh my god hes not worth it di siya singer,, di nga alam kung ano ang monotone eh….

  6. March 20, 2008 12:13 pm

    well, let’s see if they can judge the contestants well. 🙂

  7. April 21, 2008 4:47 pm

    hi.. meron pong unofficial website ng pinoy idol kaming ginawa… eto po..

    sorry for this shameless advertising…

    its unofficial though, pero it’ll be updated… and the construction is still in progress to provide videos and photo galleries.

    salamat po at pasensya na sa ad

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: